Join! 12 weeks for $1

Brown Butter-Cardamom Banana Bread

1 9-inch Loaf

1 hour 15 minutes 25 minutes active

Made This Recipe? Write a Review.
Thank you for submitting your review! A member of our team is confirming the review meets our site's Community Guidelines. It will be posted on the site shortly.

Banana bread is one of the most common baked goods made at home, and most of them taste just that — common. We wanted a revved-up recipe that would produce flavorful results without additional effort. So we paired one of banana’s most complementary spices – cardamom – with nutty browned butter. Blooming the cardamom in hot butter draws out the spice’s aromas, producing a more complex flavor in the finished bread. We found we needed two leaveners. Baking powder alone gave the bread lift but turned out a pale loaf. Baking soda resulted in a well-browned top but a dense crumb. Combining the two was perfect. Measuring the bananas in a 1-cup dry measuring cup was important; the difference in moisture between 4 small and 4 large bananas could throw off the balance of the ingredients. While we preferred the deeper flavor of dark brown sugar here, light brown works just as well. Sprinkling granulated sugar over the top of the loaf just before baking created a crisp, brown crust that we loved.

1

9-inch Loaf

Tip

Don’t measure the bananas by number, as differences in sizes can throw off the balance of ingredients. Measure them using a dry measuring cup instead.

1 hour 15 minutes

25 minutes active

Ingredients

  • 260

    grams (2 cups) all-purpose flour

  • 1

    teaspoon baking powder

Directions

Pardon the interruption

You need to be a Milk Street Digital Member to see the full recipe

JOIN MILK STREET DIGITAL & PRINT
12 WEEKS FOR JUST $1

and get access to all of our recipes and articles online, as well as in print.

GET DIGITAL & PRINT
How we use your email.

Your email address is required to identify your subscription. We will use it for customer service as well as other communications from Milk Street. We will not share, or rent your email address.

Reviews
Don D.
November 8, 2022
Insane
This is amazing. I will never make banana bread another way.
Mukta T.
November 21, 2022
The Banana Bread Recipe!
This was the banana bread I had been looking for. I thought the cardamom might be too strong, but the perfume helps banana flavor linger longer. Tried European salted butter and didn't find it too be too salty.
Hunter L.
October 29, 2022
Can this recipe be used to make muffins (or mini-muffins)?
Checking to see if anyone has used this recipe to make muffins or mini-muffins. Does the recipe need tweaking (other than reducing the baking time?) to do so?
Sue E.
June 7, 2022
Great Banana Bread
I love cardamom which is in this recipe and makes this bread special.
Roberto C.

Delicious and nice texture but too salty! Used salted butter and 1 teaspoon coarse salt as directed; try less salt or unsalted butter next time.

M R P.

I made this today and it was perfection! My husband has a love of cardamom as well as walnuts and specifically asked for banana walnut bread - so I added a good bunch to the recipe. Other than that it was perfect exactly as written. Will be making this again.

Annie W.

I've made this recipe twice. The first time, I found the cardamom taste overpowered the banana and it didn't taste banana-ey enough. The second time, I made some changes: (1) used 2.5 oz of whole wheat flour in place of 2.5 oz of the all purpose flour, (2) reduced cardamom to 1/4 tsp, (3) added 1/4 tsp of cinnamon, (4) added roasted walnuts, (5) used a 9-inch cake pan instead of the loaf pan, and (6) I shingled thin banana slices around the perimeter of the pan before sprinkling with sugar. It was done in 40 minutes (it may have been done earlier, but I didn't check it until 40 mins). It's a delicious banana cake!

Martha D.

I also found it too salty. I will cut back. I wonder if the brand of kosher salt makes a difference

Patricia D.

It does ..this is probably amount for Diamond brand. Morton is different amount...don’t remember the conversion.

Karen H.

I think coarseness makes a difference - if your kosher salt is fine, it may be too much.

Christy K.

Covid-19. Day 26. I have one black banana. I certainly don’t want to waste any food these days. The one black banana measures out to 1/2 cup ( smashed). Holycow- I’m gonna have to reduce this recipe to 1/4 of its usual volume. It’s turned out tiny and tasty. Glad I had a tiny pan.

Paulette O.

Were you successful? I hate to waste ripe bananas but usually only hove one. I thought about freezing them until i had enough but cutting the recipe might be a good option.

Ann L.

Thank you for your comment! Your comment is currently under moderation and will appear shortly.

Jessica D.

Awwww I saw the tip about measuring the bananas just now, while waiting for my banana bread (with exactly 4 bananas) to finish cooking. Hope it still turns out well!

Shelley B.

Fantastic but next time will add pecans or walnuts

Jennifer M.

is it possible to convert these recipes to weight instead of volume?

Linda W.

Definitely needs walnuts. Salt and cardamom levels were fine.

Ingrid F.

I've made this recipe 3 times now and will make it at least 30 X more to come. I did not find it a bit salty, I used Kosher Diamond Salt...that make a difference since the flake's volume takes up more room than regular salt, so half the weight. I love cardamom and did not find it too much even though I freshly ground my cardamom.

Steven P.

Thank you for your comment! Your comment is currently under moderation and will appear shortly.

Fiona G.

Are we sure about the 3/4 Cup of brown sugar? I didn’t find it sweet enough.

Nina R.

I liked this, I didn’t find it too salty but I did find the cardamom overwhelmed the banana. I absolutely love cardamom but I want to taste the banana in banana bread! I think walnuts would be a nice touch.

Charissa B.

Has anyone tried this using a Gluten-free all purpose flour?

yvonne d.

This banana bread is incredibly delicious and I have made many times. I personally dial back on the cardamom and add cinnamon as well. I use an 8x8 pan since that's what I have, and it finishes in 30 minutes. Based on other comments I'm guessing Milkstreet has made adjustments to the salt- the 1/2 teaspoon of table salt is perfect. Highly recommend! Browning the butter is a game changer!

Nicolette W.

I wanted more cardamom flavor. I will add more next time. My four bananas were not quite enough to make 2 cups, but it still turned out tasty.

Cathyanne N.

FABULOUS! I don't like banana bread at all - but get tired of throwing out overly ripe bananas. This is amazing. I truly believe the cardamom made all the difference. I may even make this as gifts. Truly wonderful - the perfect texture and flavor. I baked mine for 47 minutes so watch the time.

Ashley H.

Delicious! I didn’t find it too salty but it’s definitely cardamom forward. I think nuts or cocoa nibs/chocolate chips could be good

Lorena G.

My FAVORITE banana bread! I've made this recipe more than 10 times and I love it especially with walnuts added. My husband is not a fan of the cardamom, but I love the scent of the spice. We usually make this in a mini loaf pan of 8 2"x4" loaves for 20-25 minutes and they're perfect!