Your email address is required to begin the subscription process. We will use it for customer service and other communications from Milk Street. You can unsubscribe from receiving our emails at any time.
tablespoons extra-virgin olive oil, plus more to serve
ounces pancetta, chopped
bunch flat-leaf parsley, stems minced, leaves roughly chopped, reserved separately
teaspoons fennel seeds
cup dry white wine
Kosher salt and ground black pepper
quarts low-sodium chicken broth
cup fregola (see note)
ounce can large white beans, such as butter beans, rinsed and drained
medium garlic cloves, minced
ounces ricotta salata cheese (see note), crumbled (¾ cup)
ounces baby arugula (about 6 cups lightly packed), roughly chopped
cup lightly packed fresh tarragon, chopped
I got a subscription because I wanted this recipe (I'm a NYT Cooking loyalist but love CK and Milk Street). I must say it was totally worth it. Made it today and it's fantastic. I ate three bowls for lunch! Subbed bacon for pancetta and pecorino for ricotta salata, but other than that followed the recipe exactly. Five stars.
I made this last night. Followed directions exactly. Luckily our market had pancetta, ricotta salata, and I ordered 3 bags of fregola (so I can make more). Our house smelled amazing. This soup is so good I give it 5+ stars. This will be made over and over again. Thank you Milk Street for another amazing recipe!
I have to add that I just had leftovers for lunch and the flavors really intensified over night. This is excellent, if not better, the next day.
I loved it too!
This was absolutely wonderful. I did not use the pancetta, could not find ricotta salata at the store (used pecorino) and sub'd pearl couscous for the fregola...this will be on our regular rotation.
Just finished making this soup, totally outstanding in texture, flavour. Will make this again in a heartbeat!
I don't see the notes that I am directed to see. Can you help me find them i.e.3/4 cup fegola(see note?
The notes are mentioned in the recipe description. The note regarding fregola is as followed, "If you can’t find fregola, substitute an equal amount of pearl couscous, but cook it for only 5 minutes before adding the beans, parsley and garlic. "
The Milk Street Team
I’m gluten free what can I substitute for the fregola?
If you can't find a glutenfree version of fregola or couscous, try plain quinoa.
The Milk Street Team
A wonderful soup. I lightly crushed the fennel seeds, sauteed in bacon grease but didn't add bacon, used Greek mizithra for ricotta salata, and used basil instead of tarragon because that's what I had. I also didn't have enough chicken stock, so half the liquid was cooking liquid from the white beans I made (instead of canned). I've never really thought of arugula as an "herb" before, and it's delicious here.
I agree with all of the above, this is a delicious soup. I have to substitute cured pork belly for pancetta and pecorino for salata, those two items are not available where I live unfortunately.
Just so delighted with this soup, that I am going to make the fregola and shrimp soup next from the Sept 2019 edition.
This recipe did not initially grab me until I read the reviews and decided to give it a try. So glad I did! Like all Milk Street recipes, I'm amazed at how a fairly simple list of ingredients comes together to create something so delicious. Like others, I subbed Pecorino for the Ricotta Salata (couldn't find it) but otherwise followed exactly. The Pecorino works great with it if that's all you can find.
Yes a couple of tweaks, bacon for pancetta and old fashioned ricotta for ricotta salata. Just delicious.
It sounds sooooo good, except i'm a vegetarian. Is there a substitute for the pancetta? Maybe even just caramelize some chopped onion? or just forget about it and begin with the parsley stems and fennel seeds?
Hi Paula - Another reader above omitted the pancetta and still loved the soup so that is definitely an option. If you eat fish, you could sauté a few anchovies in the oil until they break down and then add the parsley stems and fennel seeds. Adding a few reconstituted dried mushrooms would be nice too. I wouldn't add too many and I'd chop them pretty fine. You wouldn't want the mushrooms to take over the dish. They are meant to be more of a background flavor and add some "umami" as the pancetta would. Hope that helps!
The Milk Street Team
Looks so good-- I'm about to make it. I am using Israeli couscous because I couldn't find fregola last minute. I guess I'll toast the couscous first so it looks more like the fregola in the picture, but the recipe didn't mention doing it. Good idea? I'll find out. Can't hurt, I think.