Join! 12 weeks for $1

Chocolate, Prune and Rum Cake

12 Servings

1 hr 20 min 30 min active

Made This Recipe? Write a Review.
Thank you for submitting your review! A member of our team is confirming the review meets our site's Community Guidelines. It will be posted on the site shortly.

We were smitten with Claire Ptak’s chocolate, prune and whiskey cake, but when we got the recipe back to Milk Street we knew we needed to make adjustments. Most home bakers aren’t as skilled as Ptak, and we wanted a cake people would fall in love with on the first try – as we did when we tasted her version. Her cake is deliciously gooey at the center, and we wanted to keep that. A ratio of 3:1 chocolate to butter – as well as 8 ounces of chopped pitted prunes – got us the results we wanted. We tried a variety of chocolates and preferred bar chocolates with 60 to 70 percent cacao (especially the Ghirardelli and Guittard brands). Chocolate chips contain stabilizers that can change the cake’s texture; it’s best to avoid them. Ptak uses almond flour, not an uncommon ingredient in flourless chocolate cakes such as this, but certainly not a common ingredient in American homes. In an effort to streamline, we reworked the cake a bit to leave it out and found the results just as good. At first we questioned the need to whip the egg yolks and whites separately, but we discovered it made a big difference. Whipping the yolks helps maintain the emulsion of chocolate and butter; skipping that step produced an unpleasantly dense cake. And of course by now we understood the value of under-whipping the egg whites and just barely mixing them into the batter. Ptak originally made this cake with Armagnac, but later switched to whiskey. We couldn’t easily find the former, and the latter – while delicious once the cake was cooled – tasted harsh when the cake was warm (and this cake begs to be eaten warm). We found dark rum tasted delicious warm or cooled and better complemented the molasses.

12

Servings

Tip

Don’t over-bake this cake. Don’t be alarmed if the center still jiggles a bit and yields to gentle pressure; the cake will continue to set after it comes out of the oven.

1 hr 20 min

30 min active

Ingredients

  • 9

    tablespoons (1 stick plus 1 tablespoon) salted butter (1 tablespoon softened)

  • 8

    ounces pitted prunes (about 1½ cups), finely chopped

Directions

Pardon the interruption

You need to be a Milk Street Digital Member to see the full recipe

JOIN MILK STREET DIGITAL & PRINT
12 WEEKS FOR JUST $1

and get access to all of our recipes and articles online, as well as in print.

GET DIGITAL & PRINT
How we use your email.

Your email address is required to identify your subscription. We will use it for customer service as well as other communications from Milk Street. We will not share, or rent your email address.

Reviews
Chris B.
June 23, 2022
Outstanding
Outstanding
Kat T.
September 11, 2022
Adding to the Negative Reviews
So I am not a picky eater and will end up eating this whole cake because I hate throwing food away....my family did not enjoy. My husband took one bit and threw it away and my two teenagers also did not enjoy. I used the recommended 60% ghiradelli chocoloate and followed the recipe exactly.
Michele R.

All of the ingredients are things we love and our taste buds had high expectations for flavor that weren't quite met for them in the outcome here. Made per recipe but... Side note is we found this much better the day it was baked than as leftovers the next day. We were glad we tried it but it would not be a repeat. Different strokes for different folks.

Cora D.

Completely agree with Michele's comment. This tasted off; the prunes, bittersweet chocolate, and rum combo do not taste good together. The texture of the prunes in the cake is unfortunate. It was a disappointing result considering it sounded so delicious!

Sarah W.

I made this and found it inedible. The flavor of the rum was so strong it overwhelmed any other flavors. It tasted like it had been soaked in raw alcohol. I had to throw it away.

Sam L.

We made this last night for my birthday. We should have looked at these posted comments. Both my wife and I agree , this cake was horrible . What a waste of time and ingredients.

Scott P.

No, this cake is not for everyone, but I found the flavor combo bold and delicious. I topped it with Greek-yogurt-flavored whipped cream.

Andree B.

I made this cake for Valentine’s Day, was excited by the combination of prunes, molasses and dark rum, all ingredients I love. As it baked I found the smell a bit “curious”, not the nice chocolate smell I was expecting. The cake looked beautiful and cut wonderfully with a very nice moist crumb; but the taste was disappointing. I don’t think the dark rum worked well, may try again using brandy. I agree with the comments above that the cake tasted better the second day and is certainly not for everyone, but it won’t be wasted! Topped with frozen vanilla yogurt helps tone down the “peculiar” flavour.